Commas between Independent Clauses on the SAT® and ACT® Exams

Commas between Independent Clauses on the SAT® and ACT® Exams

Important SAT Update: Transition to Digital SAT
Effective December 3, 2023, the traditional paper-and-pencil format of the SAT has been discontinued. Starting in 2024, all students are required to take the Digital SAT, ushering in substantial changes in duration, format, material coverage, and question types. This shift to the Digital SAT represents a departure from traditional testing methods. It is crucial for students, educators, and test-takers to acquaint themselves with the new examination structure. Read more about the Digital SAT here.

Both the SAT and ACT exams test comma placement between two independent clauses joined by a conjunction (FANBOYS: for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so).

In this type of sentence, the comma is placed after the first independent clause and before the conjunction.

UWorld College Prep ACT and SAT Example: Example:
Conjunction
	She calmed them down, and they were no longer afraid.
    Independent clause 1		      Independent clause 2

Most questions on the exams that require a comma between two independent clauses are like the above example.

However, the ACT has also included at least one question in which one of the independent clauses also contained an introductory phrase set off with commas, but the rule didn’t change: a comma was still needed between the independent clauses.

UWorld College Prep ACT and SAT Example: Example:
           Conjunction	         Independent clause 2
He didn't want to sell the boat, but, in September, he lost his job. 
            Independent clause 1	          Introductory phrase

An independent clause is a complete thought that contains a subject and main verb. Often, the SAT and ACT test students’ misunderstandings of this rule by including options that place commas before conjunctions when either the information before or after the conjunction isn’t an independent clause.

UWorld College Prep ACT and SAT Example: Example: Incorrect -
     Conjunction
Worried about the numbers, yet we still have enough money.
		Phrase lacks a subject		       Independent clause
Incorrect:
  Conjunction
The band is marching on the football field, so the players having left.
Independent clause			     Phrase lacks a main verb

In the above example, “having” can’t be a main verb without a helping verb.  For example,

  • “He having a good day” isn’t an independent clause. (“Having” isn’t a main verb.)
  • “He is having a good day” is an independent clause. (“Is having” is a main verb.)

If you need more practice with comma and other punctuation questions, use the released tests provided by the College Board and ACT or practice online with exam-like questions at websites like UWorld.

Scroll to Top