Should You Take Both the SAT and ACT? Pros, Cons, and Myths

Last updated: June 18th, 2025

Illustration of high school students studying for the SAT and ACT using digital and print prep tools.
Dual testing = your edge. Bust myths & boost your score with smart SAT + ACT prep advice.
Illustration of high school students studying for the SAT and ACT using digital and print prep tools.

You've probably heard it on TikTok or seen it in a meme: “Don't stress about the SAT or ACT—most schools are test-optional now!” Sounds freeing, right? But here's the truth: strong test scores can give you a competitive edge even in a test-optional world.

If you're wondering, “Should I take both the SAT and ACT?”—you're not alone. With more colleges accepting either test and more students aiming for scholarships, it's smart to explore both options. In this post, we'll break down the benefits of taking SAT and ACT, the challenges, myths you shouldn't believe, and how to prep smart without burning out.

Why This Decision Matters

The Role of Test Scores in College Admissions

Even with more schools adopting test-optional policies, over 80% of applicants still submit SAT or ACT scores, especially when applying to competitive schools or seeking merit scholarships. Why? Because a strong test score can:

  • Showcase your academic potential
  • Offset a lower GPA
  • Open doors to scholarships
  • Strengthen your overall application

And the good news? Most colleges accept both the SAT and ACT, giving you flexibility in how you present your academic strengths.

Debunking Test-Optional Myths

Let's clear something up: test-optional doesn't mean test-blind. Colleges may not require scores, but they will review them if submitted, and many admissions officers say they still prefer applicants who provide them.

Don’t assume test scores don’t matter—many students earn scholarships by submitting strong SAT or ACT results.

Pros of Taking Both the SAT and ACT

More Opportunities

Different colleges and scholarships may lean slightly toward one test. Taking both means:

  • You won't miss an opportunity because of a testing preference
  • You can highlight your best performance on either test
  • You maximize your retake windows and submission deadlines

This strategy can be a game-changer, especially if you're applying to a mix of public, private, and out-of-state schools.

Discovering Your Strengths

The SAT and ACT test similar skills, but they're not identical. For example:

  • The ACT includes a Science section
  • The SAT allows more time per question
  • Math sections differ in structure and calculator use

Trying both helps you figure out which test fits your learning and thinking style best. UWorld's platform even lets you compare your SAT vs ACT performance side by side—so you know where to focus your energy.

Flexibility in Application Strategy

Taking both tests gives you:

  • More chances to retest and improve
  • Multiple score reports to mix and match
  • A broader application portfolio to impress colleges

Some students who take both tests are surprised to score higher on the second one—sometimes the format just fits better. Submitting both scores can strengthen your application, especially to top-choice schools.

Challenges to Consider

Time and Energy

Let's be real: preparing for one test takes time. Preparing for two? That's double the effort—unless you plan smart.

That's where the UWorld ACT + SAT combo plan comes in. You get:

  • A combined SAT and ACT study schedule
  • Shared question bank access
  • Customized progress tracking tools to streamline your prep

With everything in one place, you can study smarter—not harder.

Potential for Burnout

Juggling school, extracurriculars, and test prep can be overwhelming. Without a plan, it's easy to hit a wall.

That's why UWorld uses bite-sized practice sessions, perfect for 20–30 minute blocks a few times a week. You stay consistent without feeling stressed.

Short, consistent practice sessions—like UWorld’s bite-sized drills—can help you prep effectively without burnout and improve on both the SAT and ACT.

How to Prep for Both Without Overwhelm

Smart Scheduling

Here's a sample combined SAT and ACT study schedule for juniors:

  • Fall (Junior Year): Start with one test—whichever you're most curious about
  • Winter: Begin light prep for the second test while continuing with the first
  • Spring: Take both exams with proper breaks in between
  • Summer Before Senior Year: Retake your best test (or both) to boost scores

With planning, you avoid cramming and stay in control of your timeline.

Use an All-in-One Resource

No need to jump between platforms. UWorld for SAT and ACT includes:

  • Exam-like practice questions
  • In-depth explanations with visuals
  • Built-in note-taking and flashcard tools
  • Score tracking across both tests
  • Mobile access so you can study anywhere

Whether you're solving a tough math question or reviewing grammar rules, UWorld is your one-stop prep hub.

Real Student Results with UWorld Dual Prep

UWorld students consistently report higher scores and more confidence:

“I just got my SAT scores and I got a 1510! The only prep I did was UWorld for one month and I improved 120 points. UWorld is the real deal! I was able to learn from my mistakes. It is freaking amazing!”
— Bashar
“I tried the SAT Prep! It was fantastic! It made me more comfortable with my SAT skills. I was more confident in my reading skills in history and science texts. UWorld’s question and feedback format helped me understand concepts rather than just memorizing. It was a useful tool in my SAT prep journey! I would definitely recommend!”
— UWorld forum user
“UWorld’s ACT mobile app allows students to answer quizzes as short as 5 questions anytime, for all subjects on the ACT.”
— Sojourning Scholar Review

Conclusion: Is Dual Testing Right for You?

Taking both the SAT and ACT isn't for everyone—but it can be a smart move if you:

  • Want to maximize your college and scholarship options
  • Are unsure which test suits you best
  • Have time to prepare with the right strategy

Weigh the pros and cons, think about your goals, and prep in a way that works for your schedule. If you're ready to explore both paths, UWorld's SAT + ACT Combo Plan is your ultimate companion.

👉 Try it free and get started today. Your future self will thank you.

References

Follow Us For Daily Video Tips
View More...
Scroll to Top